Owing more than your home is worth does not, by itself, mean a homeowner has decided to walk away. A strategic default on a mortgage is a deliberate decision to stop paying even though the borrower can still afford the payments, usually because the home is worth much less than the loan and is not expected to recover soon.
That distinction matters. Falling behind because of a job loss, illness or divorce is very different from choosing to stop paying, and the options and consequences can differ too. This article explains what strategic default means, how it compares with a loan modification, short sale, deed in lieu and foreclosure, and what Massachusetts homeowners in Reading and throughout Middlesex and Essex Counties should weigh before making a decision.
Key Takeaways
- Strategic default is a choice to stop paying while still able to pay. Negative equity alone does not make a default "strategic."
- A loan modification, short sale, deed in lieu and foreclosure each treat the home and the remaining debt differently.
- Stopping payments does not make the mortgage go away. Credit, future borrowing, possible remaining debt and taxes all need to be considered.
- The right path depends on your income, the home's value, the loan documents and the status of any foreclosure.
Negative Equity Is Not the Same as Default
A mortgage is "underwater" when the amount owed is more than the home's market value. The difference is the equity shortfall. A small shortfall is very different from owing far more than the home could sell for, but either way, being underwater says nothing about whether a borrower can afford the payments or plans to stop making them.
Most mortgage defaults are driven by hardship: unemployment, medical bills, divorce or other life events. A strategic default is different because the borrower could keep paying but decides the home is no longer worth the cost. Researchers measure strategic default in different ways and over different time periods, so national estimates of how often it happens should not be read as a current figure for Massachusetts.
Why Some Homeowners Consider Walking Away
Surveys of homeowners have found that willingness to walk away tends to grow as the equity shortfall grows, and that people also weigh moving costs, their other finances and their own views about fairness and obligation. A homeowner whose shortfall is temporary may reach a very different decision than one who expects the property to remain underwater for years.
Alternatives: Loan Modification, Short Sale, Deed in Lieu and Foreclosure
Massachusetts homeowners often have more than one way to address a mortgage they can no longer afford or no longer want. The best option depends on affordability, the home's value and how the lender responds.
- Loan modification. The lender agrees to change the loan terms, such as the interest rate, term or payment, so that the homeowner can keep the home. Learn more about loan modifications.
- Short sale. The home is sold for less than the loan balance with the lender's approval. See our short sale page and how a short sale affects your credit.
- Deed in lieu of foreclosure. The homeowner transfers ownership to the lender instead of going through foreclosure.
- Foreclosure. The lender follows the legal process to take and sell the property after default.
These options differ in whether you keep the home, how the remaining balance is handled, and how long it may be before you can qualify for another mortgage. Lender and loan-program rules on waiting periods vary, so ask about the specific rules that apply to your situation before you decide.
Remaining Debt and Deficiency Claims
A deficiency is the gap between what is owed on the mortgage and what the property brings at a foreclosure sale. Whether a Massachusetts homeowner could be pursued for a deficiency depends on the loan documents, any second mortgage or home equity line, the notices the lender sent and how the sale was conducted. Do not assume that walking away ends your liability. An attorney can review the note, the mortgage and the sale details to assess your exposure.
Credit, Taxes and Future Borrowing
A default and foreclosure can significantly damage your credit and make it harder to borrow, including for a future home. If a lender forgives part of the debt, that canceled debt may also have tax consequences. Our office does not provide tax advice; please consult a CPA or tax professional about the tax effect of any canceled mortgage debt.
Staying in the Home During Foreclosure
Homeowners can usually remain in the property while a foreclosure is pending, but after a foreclosure sale the new owner can seek possession. Read every notice from your lender or the new owner carefully, note its dates and deadlines, and get advice promptly. Waiting can close off options that would otherwise be available.
Before You Decide
Strategic default is a decision about payments, not just about the home's value. Before stopping payments, look honestly at your income, the mortgage balance, the home's value, your other obligations and what you want to protect. Walking away is a serious step that involves the lender, the home and your future finances, and it is difficult to undo.
If broader debt is part of the picture, Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy may also be worth discussing. Chapter 13, in particular, can sometimes give homeowners a way to catch up on arrears and keep the home. See how to stop foreclosure in Massachusetts for more.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens when you default on a mortgage?
Missed payments can lead the lender to begin foreclosure, which may end with the home being sold. The process can take months or longer. Default can also damage your credit and make future borrowing more difficult.
Can I still owe money after a foreclosure in Massachusetts?
Possibly. Whether a deficiency can be pursued depends on the loan and the circumstances of the sale. Do not assume every mortgage is non-recourse. Have the loan documents and sale information reviewed.
How does strategic default compare with a short sale, deed in lieu or loan modification?
Strategic default means stopping payments without first reaching a resolution with the lender. A short sale sells the home for less than the balance with the lender's cooperation; a deed in lieu transfers the home to the lender; a loan modification changes the loan terms so you can keep the home. Compare the terms, the treatment of any remaining debt and the effect on your credit before choosing.
Will a strategic default hurt my credit?
Yes. A mortgage default and foreclosure can significantly lower your credit score and affect your ability to get another mortgage for some time.
Talk With a Reading, MA Attorney
The Law Office of Matthew T. Desrochers, P.C. has helped Massachusetts homeowners and families for over 25 years. Attorney Desrochers can review your mortgage, your options and the possible consequences before you make a decision you cannot easily reverse. We offer free consultations.
Call (781) 279-1822 or contact us online. Our office is located at 274 Main Street, Suite 208, Reading, MA 01867, and we serve clients throughout Middlesex and Essex Counties.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every situation is different; consult an attorney about your specific circumstances. Attorney Advertising.
